HOW do your Comments Create Value?

Content marketing really isn’t all that new. But using it to promote one’s business has become A LOT easier with the advent of social media. The key is making your message helpful, useful, or inspiring… and especially SHAREABLE.

Case in point: A few days ago I put out a tweet that illustrated a simple, but profound truth about content marketing.

google plus AnaIt got favorited, retweeted, commented on by lots of great Twitter followers. Some of which are pretty heavy hitters.

That’s Ana Hoffman and Ryan Hanley talking about my quote in there!
<===

And that simple, tweetable tweet paved the way for THIS post you are reading today.

By the way, did you catch the significance of that one thought? “Any fool can count the seeds in an apple. It takes God to count the apples that can come from a seed. Keep Planting!”

Think about it: plant ONE seed, get an apple tree. Plant the seeds from the apples that the first tree produces… and you have a whole freakin’ orchard.

Content marketing is like that. It’s about sowing seeds. But the quality of the seeds sown determines what you are going to grow in you blog, your business, your life.

What are YOU Planting?

So a single seed can yield an orchard. Sounds just gravy, but…

Maybe I don’t particularly care for apples. I do care for the principle though.

What to sow?

Whatever you put out there, especially with consistency, cultivation and care… you will get back a hundredfold.

“The life of the seed is in itself.” This means that if you plant a cherry tree, you won’t get peaches. You’ll get cherries. Plant corn and you get corn, not squash. Peanuts to peas, okra to acorns… you get back what you put in.

So, whaddoo we wanna harvest?

If it’s criticism and strife, all we have to do is act like a jerk. We’ll get it back, honest.

If we want to be targeted for opportunism, all we need to do is target others. Ever go to a “networking meeting” where folks aresalesperson-cheesy frantically whipping out their business cards and listening to you just long enough so they can tell you what THEY sell? Me too. I’ve met the same Networking Guy (same guy, different face)  about two dozen times over in the same two hours. Never again.

We harvest what we sow, SO…

If we want to be recommended by others, we should provide recommendations.

If we want credibility, we should recognize truth spoken by others.

If we want help, we should be helpful.

As the saying goes: “To find a friend… BE a friend.”

How Does Commenting on Other’s Blogs CREATE Value?

Well, first let’s define value “creation”.

Like you. So I give you $100. That blesses you so much that you give me $100 as well.

Value has been exchanged but no value has been created. We’re both in the same state as before, right?

On the other hand, say I have more chocolate than I can eat. And you have more coffee than you can drink. Giving one another what we have but don’t need, gives us BOTH what we need, but don’t have.

And, uh… Yeah. I’d say that coffee and chocolate are both fundamental human needs 😉

Value is created when people share what they uniquely produce.

Value Production Is NOT Value Creation

Another analogy: You’re a dairy farmer. I farm wheat.

We both produce things of value.

But, dang.

There’s only so much milk, cream, yogurt, cheese and butter one guy can eat, right?

Together, we can give the world buttered toast.

By joining forces we have milk and cereal.

And grilled cheese sammiches. Mmm. 😉

Our sharing creates value.

For ourselves and others.

True Value Creation Benefits EVERYone

“Hey Frankenberg, I thought this blog post was gonna be about blog commenting.”

Yeah, yeah. Gettin’ there. Just wanted to lay the groundwork first.

So, the most obvious benefit about commenting on other’s blogs is that doing so generates a link and can lead to traffic for you. salesperson-cheesy

(“Here’s my bidness card, gimme your bidness card. Ooh I gotta go talk to that guy. Check, check, ohhhh yeah. You’re great. I mean that, honest. I’ll call you.”)

But that misses the point. Linking is a side benefit… it’s really the least valuable thing going on here, though for some it’s become their main focus.

Let’s change that.

Please, please don’t comment on this kid’s blog if all you’re here to do is glom on a link, then head out to do the same to fifteen others.

But if you’re concerned about creating value for everyone, by all means. Stay. Chat a bit. Love ta hear from ya.

Value Creation, Bill Nye Style

Bill Nye, the Science Guy is known for a wonderful quotable quote: “Everyone you will ever meet knows something you don’t.”

ss101 bill nyeThis one fact is one reason that we need to respect everyone we meet.

Because everyone has knowledge that others need. Including you.

And knowledge is power, n’est-ce pas?

Respect, Bill. Nice quote.

So taking the analogy of sharing what we produce… the wheat guy shares with the milk guy and the whole world gets buttered toast…

…each of us produces valuable, unique ideas…

…but sharing those ideas, creates something of greater value. Greater value that we couldn’t possibly arrive at on our own.

Less Obvious,  More Important Benefits of Blog Commenting

This idea-sharing dynamic is so vital. By adding your ideas to others, you truly create value.

You create value for the blogger by:

  • Giving him/her “buzz“… the social proof that what they are saying is worth reading
  • Adding credibility; don’t you raise your eyebrows and pay attention to a post with +100 comments?
  • Adding to the conversation… thoughts that may become new topics and posts
  • Giving recognition and appreciation. This blogging thang can be HARD. Nice to know someone with a pulse is readin’.
  • Reaching out and being a friend. To have a friend, BE a friend.

You create value for yourself by:

  • Using your voice. You establish your own authority with what you add to the conversation.
  • Honing your own writing skills. You may write without the pressure of it being on your own blog.
  • Engaging the author and perhaps getting a detailed answer to questions you ask.
  • Stimulating your own thought process. Writing about what you read enhances your retention.
  • Getting ideas for writing similar posts of your own. Without plagiarizing! Credit anyone that helps your process.
  • Reaching out and gaining a friend. This friendship may lead to an alliance or not, but friendship is most important.

You create value for others by:

  • Encouraging others to add their own thoughts.
  • Engaging others with questions or comments on their comments.
  • Entertaining others by giving a playful spin on what is written.
  • Adding to the storehouse of knowledge on the blogger’s subject.
  • Raising the level of discussion and interest in the topic. “A rising tide lifts all boats.”

Yes, the comment you leave makes for a link back to your own content that may increase your traffic. But again, that’s a side benefit that pales in comparison to the fifteen (sixteen… I came back and added yet another!) other valuable benefits I’ve listed here, as well as the ones I’ve forgotten or overlooked.

Hey, maybe a commenter can help me add what’s missing 😉

Sow WHAT? <=== Oooh, see that pun?

So what, Kurt?

Are you saying I should feel guilty for commenting on blogs to get links?

Aww, mercy. No.

I’m just saying that link building oughtta be a side effect, NOT the main focus of our comment activity.

Every single comment I leave… or expect to receive…  is aimed at creating oodles of value, for myself, for others. Not just a link building strategy comparable to a virtual business card toss.

What we reap, we sow.

Know what I want on my blog?ryan hanley

I want respect.nicholas

I want credibility.

I want “buzz.”

I want engagement, entertainment, lucid and relevant thoughts jammin’ with other smart fellas and fellerettes.kristi-hines-200

I want great comments, from great commenters.

SO… I’ll go out and sow that which I wish to reap.

I’ll be respectful. Add credibility. Create buzz. Engage, entertain.

I’ll be giving out what I want to get back.

I’ll quit fightin’ over how big of a slice of pie I can get, and instead… leverage relationships with other thinkers. To cook a better pie forana all to partake.

And I want to encourage YOU to do the same.

On that note, dear Reader…

Would love to hear your comments. 😎

Keep Stepping,

Kurt

Comments

  1. Comments generate back links and they also helps in expanding the business or brand awareness.

  2. Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m happy to find so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.

  3. Hey Kurt,

    So you know I’ve had somewhat of a busy week and I’m just now getting by here but I did not forget about you sharing this post with me.

    The great news is that even though it’s over a year old boy is it still very relevant. I couldn’t agree with you more.

    You really did explain the art of commenting. When I started this process I was doing it because I was told it would drive traffic to my blog. The funny thing is that I started learning so much from these posts that I was in awe how helpful these bloggers were. The next thing you know I’m so appreciative of what I’ve been learning that I totally forgot all about the traffic. I was commenting because I loved learning what they were teaching me and I wanted them to know it.

    That started getting some serious attention and the next thing you know I’ve built some darn great relationships from it. I oftentimes tell people to not worry about being seen, the backlinks or even the comments. Think about the people you’ll have the opportunity to meet, what you’ll learn from them and the relationships that can be formed. I have my own arsenal of support now that I can call on for just about anything.

    Really great share Kurt, thanks for pointing me this way. Right up my alley and my favorite subject. 😉 Great job my friend.

    Have a wonderful weekend now, you know I will. Celebrating a successful product launch. Yay!!!

    ~Adrienne

    P.S. I love apples but hate coffee!
    Adrienne recently posted…Everything You Need To Know About Building A Blog CommunityMy Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      “You really did explain the art of commenting”.
      ENORMOUS compliment, coming from the Master Duchess of Commenting!

      I must say that the relationships I’ve built with others in this content marketing/blogging space have been the most rewarding part of the journey. You are certainly one of the greats and I hope to get to know you better.

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…The Most AWESOME Paradox… Doing Less Can Accomplish MOREMy Profile

  4. Kurtf, thank you for a wonderful and inspiring article. Before I even got to the comments section, I had a feeling that we were speaking the same language. Not surprisingly, it turns out that I also know the mutual friend you and Ana Hoffman mentioned.

    I completely agree with Gail Gardner’s observations gardening, time, and patience. As a gardener and an entrepreneur, I am often struck by the parallels between the two. And on more than one occasion, the very existence of that luscious, just-picked tomato in my salad has encouraged me to believe in that unseen harvest my business is bringing forth, regardless of the day-to-day challenges that sometimes cause me to doubt. After all, a plant’s roots grow and prosper unseen.

    I am very much looking forward to learning from you and so many others I have discovered in the comments. I’ll talk to our mutual friend and ask Him to be sure to watch over you and your work.

  5. Commenting is my number one source of free traffic and SEO at the moment. In 2013, I think Blog Commenting is the best way to build an audience to your blog. Especially if you are helpful with your comments. Over the next few weeks I’ll be writing a massive post about Blog Commenting, so watch out for some great tips and techniques.
    Mark G McKnight recently posted…Simple Traffic Solutions: Will They Work For You? – ReviewMy Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      Hi again Mark. I have to say that blog commenting has been very helpful to me but not as much in terms of heightened traffic, but rather the quality of the traffic– the friends I have made, the ideas that have been stimulated both for me and those to whom I’ve contributed thoughts. The conversation is what’s important to me. Looking forward to your post on commenting Mark.

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

  6. Hi Kurtf,
    You got me glued to the screen on this one. The facts, the quotes, the pictures, etc
    Yes man. If we comment for the reasons you mentioned, I think this commenting exercise will be more valuable. I have got to hook up with so many bloggers through commenting. That’s the winning part of it. Relationship building in blogging brings more exposure, backlinks, traffic, profit, etc. That’s why I think bloggers should focus on this facet of commenting rather than just trying to link back.

    I can quickly identify those folks commenting for backlinks’ sake – Most of them don’t fully go through the articles. They leave short and most often meaningless comments. Some try to make the comments long by saying thrash 😉 You get a whole bunch of some so-called SEO expert or Fiverr backlinkers into this whole thing.

    Well, maybe this gives your post +100 comments and adds to your social proof. However, I care about value in the comments more than the comment count 😉

    Thanks for a nice read this week
    Enstine Muki recently posted…Get your free copies of CashDonator Pro and ViralBird Traffic Script!My Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      Hiya Enstine!

      Your sentence, “…I care more about value in the commments than the comment count” got me thinking.

      On the wall in the wrestling gym in my high school it was written: “It’s not the hours you put in; it’s what you put in the hours.”

      SO, it’s not the comment count that counts, it’s making your comments count.

      Count on it.

      SIGH… SOrry to pun-nish you, just couldn’t resist that last part.

      Thanks for adding some value to my page Enstine. I’ll come check out yours now.

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

  7. Hi Kurt!

    Love your philosophy on blog commenting and how you create value for everyone involved! There is a lot of comment spam and people participating in it specifically for links which just plain sucks but if there’s a way to manipulate the system people find it. Oh, btw… your metaphors are fantastic! It truly helps paint a clearer picture. Thanks!

    Nichole
    Nichole recently posted…9 Ways to Fuel Your Inspiration for Blog ContentMy Profile

  8. “This one fact is one reason that we need to respect everyone we meet.
    Because everyone has knowledge that others need. Including you.
    And knowledge is power, n’est-ce pas?
    Respect, Bill. Nice quote.”

    Respect, Indeed. Kurt, you are right when you talk about what we sow — it could be those little updates on Twitter ( and a host of other platforms), blog posts, comments on blog posts, responses ( or questions on Quora), and so many other ways we try to “create” value on our way to eventually “share value”.

    Here are a few other things commenting on blogs creates value:

    1. You show up — thereby fulfilling that one “to do” for success later. (value for yourself)
    2. You reach out and you fill that void — the bridge — that someone has to build. (( value for yourself and others)
    3. Leaving good comments is hard work. Any meaningful work is liberating. (value for yourself and others)
    4. Comments are those little bricks that can weave the web together (value for yourself and others)
    5. Comments lead to acquaintances. Acquaintances become friends or business partners. Two or more people bring their own personality, skills, and experience to the table and we get “shared value”. Grilled cheese sammiches? 🙂 Yeah, that happens too.
    6. Your voice is heard. Goodness comes rolling in.

    Tell me if I missed something. Loved the post. Keep them blazing 🙂
    Ash recently posted…5 User Experience Issues that are Critical to Stakeholders TodayMy Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      Thanks Ash, that’s JUST what I was asking for: more ways that value is created, that I may have missed.
      Thanks for taking the time to come by and visit, then add to the conversation. Makes me wanna come over and lookit YER blog.
      Okay, that’s it. I’m outta here, comin’ to your place!

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

  9. Another awesome post Kurt. And that is meant sincerely, not as a hit and run comment.

    As a newbie blogger I’ve been creating backlinks via comments (among other tactics). In my search for quality blogs to link to I’ve discovered some incredible blogs such as shoestring101.com and trafficgenerationcafe.com. I have already learned so much from Kurt and from Ana Hoffman.

    To illustrate what a small world we live in, Kurt, in a response to my comment on one of his recent posts, offered me a truly useful tip for my readers. I ran with it; created a post, fully crediting Kurt and throwing in some links to shoestring101.com. I knew they were pingbacks, maybe trackbacks, I wasn’t quite sure.

    Today I opened an email from Ana that explained pingbacks and trackbacks. From her post I discovered I had created the links to shoestring101 WRONG. Doh! I linked to the home page and to a category page. No place for comments. I immediately went back to my post and changed out the links. Great timing Ana!

    Anyway, I’m not so sure my comments create value for anyone else, but I sure as heck am receiving incredible insight from your replies to my comments on your posts! Kurt, you are right on with your take on commenting. It’s about building relationships and sowing seeds; not just link building.
    Sylvia recently posted…CrowdfundingMy Profile

  10. Hi Kurt,

    Thanks for sharing this! Valuable insight 🙂

    For me, it doesn’t matter about the length (but don’t make it too short). Just make sure you are leaving genuine comment with some ‘human touch’ instead of “Hi thanks for the share. Bye”.

    Lastly (on the article itself), dude you nailed it with all the images etc! I think I understand why Ana said that she enjoyed reading your article.

    Keep it up and I bookmarked your site.

    Thanks again!
    Reginald recently posted…CommentLuv Premium Comment Plugin: Love It Or Hate It?My Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      Ha! I like that “Cheesy networking guy” image especially. Check, check, see ya soon. Check, gotcha.

      It’s nice to make your acquaintance Reginald. I’ll head over promptly to take a look at your blog.

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

  11. Not sure if I told you this in the past, Kurt, but yours is one of VERY few blogs I actually enjoy reading from cover to cover – it’s like having a chat with a friend over a perfectly brewed cuppa espresso… Love your style!

    And yes, commenting does move mountains, even the kind that don’t seem to be moving in the beginning.

    Now let me think about how I can share this post on G+ to provide the most value to others. lol
    Ana Hoffman recently posted…How to Write a Great Blog Post • Confession of a Bad WriterMy Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      Ana! Thanks for the kind words. Yer blog is in the same category for me: one that I actually ENJOY reading. Caffeinated or not, it keeps my attention wrapped.

      Thing is, the info is so densely packed I often have to visit the same post(s) again and again. There is so much value per paragraph it’s ridiculous. If you should write a book or offer a webinar at any time, I am your first customer. And put me first in line to help you in any way I can. For example, I’ve done very well with info products I’ve made out of recordings from webinars.

      Thanks for putting our mutual best friend in mind, He that taught us to speak, believe, and not doubt… and even this mountain will go from here to there.

      Thanks for sharing my post on G+, it looks like THIS is a network I need to start figgering out even more than Twitter. Any posts of yours or anyone in your network that you would recommend first to learn Google Plus?

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

  12. I love this post because commenting is more about building relationships and collaborations than links. We have to sow many seeds and have faith that they will grow into a nice return IN TIME. Bloggers who garden may have an advantage because they understand that concept. Small businesses and bloggers need to stop focusing on the easy – but unreliable – traffic from Google and plant all the seeds they can.

    Great analogy that your harvest depends on what you’re sowing. Few really think about what they are creating. For example, some believe my blog makes a lot of money. It doesn’t, because money isn’t what I focus on. If you want to make money, you have to seek out those who are already successful and get them to teach you what they are planting. That’s what I’m doing now that my harvest of collaborators is ripe.
    Gail Gardner recently posted…How Brad Campbell Made Over $35,000 Last Month ~ Find Out If YOU Could, TooMy Profile

    • kurtf
      Twitter:
      says:

      “…commenting is more about building relationships and collaborations than links.” Right you are, Gail!

      I appreciate the relationship I am enjoying with you as well as others in this space. At the time of this writing, I haven’t monetized Shoestring101 at all. But at some point I will. Right NOW is the time for cultivating, both the content on SS101 and the relationships with other awesome bloggers like YOU.

      Thanks for the attention and time you’ve shown THIS baby blogger. When I’m in a position to help you with anything, be assured that I’l be there.

      Keep Stepping,

      Kurt
      kurtf recently posted…HOW do your Comments Create Value?My Profile

Trackbacks

  1. […] HOW do your Comments Create Value? – Kurt Frankenberg at shoestring101.com […]

  2. […] HOW do your Comments Create Value? – Kurt Frankenberg at shoestring101.com […]

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge